Quote: (Originally Posted by
Tim Franks)

Thanks everyone. Michael, either I wasn't clear or you misunderstood. I do appreciate the importance of a quality back up - hence this post. What I was trying to say about the expensive LED versions is that the main advantage appears to be a long battery life. I just feel that this would lead users into not changing batteries as frequently as they perhaps ought. My back ups are tested pre dive, turned off and left off. I then replace batteries frequently. What I'm after is something which I know has been tested and works. I thought the salvo RAT looked good, with two 'o' rings but now I can only get the LED version - it looks extra expensive especially compaired with the Scout which I can still buy with a normal halogen bulb.
While the extra burn time of LEDs is great the most important advantage IMO is they are almost bullet proof. Turn on your halogen light & bump it, there is a good chance you will break the bulb, on a hid just look at it crossly. With a LED light you could turn it on & beat the housing to death, those little LEDs will still work as long as they have juice. There is a reason everyone is going to them. Get a LED light you will be pleased. The main problem is deciding which one, there are more good ones coming out regularly, with falling prices on the high end stuff.
RAL